Vigil/Take Profit Trader vs TopStep/for Swing Trading
Tier 2Tier 1for Swing Trading

Take Profit Trader vs TopStep for Swing Trading

Take Profit Trader is better for swing trading. News trading is unrestricted. Updated March 2026.

Verdict for Swing Trading

Recommendation: Take Profit Trader is the better choice for swing trading.

Take Profit Trader is better for swing trading. News trading is unrestricted.

Take Profit TraderTopStep
Overnight HoldingNot allowedNot allowed
Weekend HoldingNot allowedNot allowed
News Tradingallowedallowed
Min Trading DaysNoneNone
Max Drawdown TypeTrailing EOD (floor moves up at end of day)Trailing EOD (floor moves up at end of day)
Consistency RuleNoneNo single day > 50% of total profit
Inactivity Limit30 daysNone
Swing Trading Analysis

Swing trading requires holding positions for days or weeks. The most critical rules are overnight and weekend holding policies. Take Profit Trader requires you to flatten before market close. TopStep requires flattening before close. Neither firm supports true multi-day swing trades, which severely limits this strategy.

Weekend gaps can make or break swing trades. Take Profit Trader requires closing all positions before the weekend, forcing premature exits on Friday. TopStep also requires flattening before the weekend.

News events are part of swing trading life. You will inevitably hold through NFP, FOMC, or CPI releases. Take Profit Trader has no news trading restrictions. TopStep is unrestricted.

Free download

Get the full 20+ firm comparison spreadsheet.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Not sure which firm is right for you?

Answer 5 questions. Get a personalized recommendation based on your trading style, risk tolerance, and budget.

Take the Prop Firm Finder Quiz

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I hold positions overnight with Take Profit Trader and TopStep?

Take Profit Trader does not allow overnight holding. TopStep does not allow it. Neither firm allows overnight holding, so pure swing trading is not viable with either.

Can I hold trades over the weekend on Take Profit Trader or TopStep?

Take Profit Trader requires flattening before weekend holding. TopStep requires flattening before weekend holding. Weekend gaps carry risk, but swing traders on higher timeframes need this flexibility.

Is Take Profit Trader or TopStep better for trading news events?

Take Profit Trader fully allows news trading. TopStep fully allows it. Swing traders often need to hold through news events like NFP and FOMC, so unrestricted news trading is a significant advantage.

Other Comparisons: Take Profit Trader vs TopStep