Vigil/Take Profit Trader vs The5%ers/-- Cheapest Option
Tier 2Tier 1Cheapest Option

Take Profit Trader vs The5%ers -- Cheapest Option

The5%ers offers better value per dollar of trading capital. At $95 for a $20,000 account, you pay less per $10K of buying power than Take Profit Trader's $150 for $25,000. Over 3 attempts, that saves you 165 in fees. Updated March 2026.

Verdict -- Cheapest Option

Recommendation: The5%ers is the better choice -- cheapest option.

The5%ers offers better value per dollar of trading capital. At $95 for a $20,000 account, you pay less per $10K of buying power than Take Profit Trader's $150 for $25,000. Over 3 attempts, that saves you 165 in fees.

Take Profit TraderThe5%ers
Cheapest Account Fee$150$95
Cheapest Account Size$25,000$20,000
Fee per $10K Capital$60$48
Cost of 3 Attempts$450$285
Profit Split (start)80%50%
Profit Split (max)90%100%
Payout FrequencyWeeklyBi-weekly
Cost Analysis

The sticker price is not the real cost of a prop firm challenge. Most traders need 3-5 attempts to pass, so multiply the fee accordingly. Take Profit Trader's cheapest account ($25,000) costs $150 per attempt. The5%ers's cheapest ($20,000) costs $95.

Cost per dollar of capital is a better metric than raw fee. Take Profit Trader charges 60 per $10K of capital. The5%ers charges 48 per $10K. The firm with the lower ratio gives you more buying power for your money.

Profit splits determine your long-term earnings. Take Profit Trader starts at 80% (up to 90%), while The5%ers starts at 50% (up to 100%). A 10% difference in profit split matters far more than a $50 difference in challenge fees over a year of funded trading.

Free download

Get the full 20+ firm comparison spreadsheet.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Not sure which firm is right for you?

Answer 5 questions. Get a personalized recommendation based on your trading style, risk tolerance, and budget.

Take the Prop Firm Finder Quiz

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper, Take Profit Trader or The5%ers?

The5%ers starts at $95, making it the cheaper option. However, compare the cost per dollar of trading capital: Take Profit Trader gives you $25,000 for that fee, while The5%ers gives you $20,000 for $95.

How much do multiple attempts cost for Take Profit Trader vs The5%ers?

If it takes 3 attempts (industry average), Take Profit Trader costs $450 total, while The5%ers costs $285. At 5 attempts, Take Profit Trader costs $750 vs $475 for The5%ers.

Which firm has the better profit split, Take Profit Trader or The5%ers?

Take Profit Trader offers 80-90% profit split. The5%ers offers 50-100%. The5%ers has a higher maximum split. The profit split matters more than fees over time, since you will earn from it every month once funded.

Other Comparisons: Take Profit Trader vs The5%ers