Blue Guardian logo

Blue Guardian vs Take Profit Trader

Take Profit Trader logo

Source review:

Source checked Mar 21, 2026 | Primary source: Blue Guardian and Take Profit Trader official rules

Blue Guardian uses static (floor never moves) drawdown with 85-85% profit split. Take Profit Trader uses trailing eod (floor moves up at end of day) drawdown with 80-90% profit split. Blue Guardian starts at $99, Take Profit Trader starts at $150.

KEY FACTS

Blue Guardian: Static (floor never moves), 85-85% split, from $99
Take Profit Trader: Trailing EOD (floor moves up at end of day), 80-90% split, from $150
Daily loss: 4% vs 2.2%
Max split: 85% vs 90%
Markets: forex, indices, commodities, crypto vs futures

Blue Guardian vs Take Profit Trader: Which Firm Is Better?

Blue Guardian uses static (floor never moves) with a 4% daily loss limit and 85-85% profit split. Take Profit Trader uses trailing eod (floor moves up at end of day) with a 2.2% daily loss limit and 80-90% profit split. Blue Guardian starts from $99; Take Profit Trader from $150.

If you want more forgiving drawdown rules, Blue Guardian is the better choice. Static drawdown means your profits create genuine breathing room, while Take Profit Trader's trailing eod (floor moves up at end of day) raises the floor as you profit. Take Profit Trader offers a higher maximum profit split (90% vs 85%), which adds up significantly over time.

How to Choose Between Blue Guardian and Take Profit Trader

1. Start with drawdown type. If one firm uses static and the other does not, that is usually the biggest structural edge for the static-drawdown firm.

2. Check whether your actual market and holding style fit. A cheaper firm is irrelevant if it blocks the products or holding windows your strategy needs.

3. Use profit split and payout frequency as secondary filters after survivability and rule-fit are clear.

Choose Blue Guardian if...

  • You want the more forgiving drawdown model, and Blue Guardian is the only one here using static drawdown.
  • You need access to forex, indices, commodities, crypto, which Take Profit Trader does not offer in this comparison.
  • You want the cheaper starting path at $99.

Choose Take Profit Trader if...

  • You need access to futures, which Blue Guardian does not offer in this comparison.

Evidence Driving This Comparison

  • Blue Guardian uses static (floor never moves) while Take Profit Trader uses trailing eod (floor moves up at end of day).
  • Blue Guardian starts at $99, while Take Profit Trader starts at $150.
  • Blue Guardian pays 85-85% and Take Profit Trader pays 80-90%.
  • Blue Guardian allows news trading; Take Profit Trader allows it.
  • Blue Guardian allows weekend holding; Take Profit Trader does not allow weekend holding.

Highlighted differences in the table below are the fields where these two firms diverge most materially for traders.

Blue Guardian

Evaluation Type
2-step
Drawdown Type
Static (floor never moves)
Daily Loss Limit
4%
Max Drawdown
8%
Profit Target
8%
Min Trading Days
3
Profit Split
85-85%
Payout Frequency
Bi-weekly
News Trading
allowed
Overnight Holding
Yes
Weekend Holding
Yes
EA / Bots
Allowed
Markets
forex, indices, commodities, crypto
Platforms
MT4, MT5
Cheapest Account
$99 ($10,000)

Take Profit Trader

Evaluation Type
1-step
Drawdown Type
Trailing EOD (floor moves up at end of day)
Daily Loss Limit
2.2%
Max Drawdown
3%
Profit Target
6%
Min Trading Days
None
Profit Split
80-90%
Payout Frequency
Weekly
News Trading
allowed
Overnight Holding
No
Weekend Holding
No
EA / Bots
Allowed
Markets
futures
Platforms
NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView
Cheapest Account
$150 ($25,000)
Source: (verified )Source: (verified )Source: Source:

Drawdown Type Comparison: Blue Guardian vs Take Profit Trader

Scalping / Day Trading

Blue Guardian allows overnight holding, giving more flexibility. Blue Guardian's static drawdown is more forgiving for scalpers.

Swing Trading

Blue Guardian is better — allows weekend holding. Take Profit Trader requires you to flatten before close.

Budget-Conscious

Blue Guardian is cheaper to start ($99 vs $150).

Who Should Choose Blue Guardian?

Blue Guardian is the better fit if you focus on forex and CFDs. The static drawdown means every dollar of profit adds to your safety cushion, making it ideal for traders who build equity gradually and want protection from losing streaks.

  • +Static drawdown — floor never moves
  • +News trading allowed in all phases
  • +Overnight and weekend holding allowed
  • +85% profit split from the start

Blue Guardian supports MT4, MT5 and processes payouts bi-weekly. News trading is fully allowed, so you can trade NFP, FOMC, and CPI without restrictions. Both overnight and weekend holding are permitted, giving swing traders full flexibility. Automated trading with EAs is permitted.

Community reputation: 4.1/5 on Trustpilot (1,100 reviews)

Who Should Choose Take Profit Trader?

Take Profit Trader is the better fit if you trade futures exclusively. The EOD trailing drawdown gives you flexibility during the session since the floor only updates at the close, which suits active day traders who have intraday swings.

  • +No minimum trading days
  • +No consistency rule
  • +EOD trailing drawdown (not intraday)
  • +Weekly payouts

Take Profit Trader supports NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView and processes payouts weekly. News trading is fully allowed, so you can trade NFP, FOMC, and CPI without restrictions. Automated trading with EAs is permitted.

Community reputation: 4.4/5 on Trustpilot (1,700 reviews)

Audit Your Trades Against Blue Guardian or Take Profit Trader Rules

Comparing rules on paper is step one. Step two: check whether your actual trades follow them. Pick either firm below and paste a trade to see which rules you break.

Blue Guardian

Run a Free Audit

Check a trade against Blue Guardian's rules. Sign in to save results and unlock the full verdict list.

Blue Guardian
▶Add trade details (optional)

Take Profit Trader

Run a Free Audit

Check a trade against Take Profit Trader's rules. Sign in to save results and unlock the full verdict list.

Take Profit Trader
▶Add trade details (optional)

Bottom Line: Blue Guardian vs Take Profit Trader

Choosing between Blue Guardian and Take Profit Trader comes down to three things: the markets you trade, how much drawdown flexibility you need, and your budget. If you trade forex or indices or commodities or crypto, Blue Guardian is your only option here. If you trade futures, go with Take Profit Trader. Blue Guardian is cheaper to get started at $99 vs $150.

The biggest structural difference is drawdown type: Blue Guardian uses static (floor never moves) while Take Profit Trader uses trailing eod (floor moves up at end of day). Static drawdown is objectively more forgiving because profits create a permanent cushion. Trailing drawdown follows your equity peaks, meaning you can lose an account even while net profitable. If you are still undecided, take the firm finder quiz for a personalized recommendation based on your trading style, risk tolerance, and budget.

Markets: Blue Guardian vs Take Profit Trader

Blue Guardian offers forex, indices, commodities, crypto while Take Profit Trader offers futures. Only Blue Guardian provides forex, indices, commodities, crypto. Only Take Profit Trader provides futures. This is often the deciding factor -- choose the firm that covers the instruments you actually trade.

Free download

Get the full 20+ firm comparison spreadsheet with drawdown rules, fees, and payout data.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Not sure which firm is right for you?

Answer 5 questions. Get a personalized recommendation based on your trading style, risk tolerance, and budget.

Take the Prop Firm Finder Quiz

No public community benchmark yet for this firms page. Run an audit to help build anonymized violation patterns and compliance benchmarks for traders researching this setup.

Vigil only publishes aggregate trends after enough private audits exist to avoid thin, misleading samples.

Contribute an Audit

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Blue Guardian and Take Profit Trader?

The main difference between Blue Guardian and Take Profit Trader is drawdown type: Blue Guardian uses static (floor never moves) while Take Profit Trader uses trailing eod (floor moves up at end of day). Blue Guardian has a 4% daily loss limit vs Take Profit Trader's 2.2%. Profit splits are 85-85% vs 80-90%.

Is Blue Guardian or Take Profit Trader cheaper?

Blue Guardian is cheaper to start. Blue Guardian's smallest account costs $99 ($10,000), while Take Profit Trader starts at $150 ($25,000).

Which is better for beginners, Blue Guardian or Take Profit Trader?

For beginners, Blue Guardian may be more forgiving. Blue Guardian's static drawdown means profits add extra buffer, which is safer for new traders. Also consider that Blue Guardian is a 2-step evaluation while Take Profit Trader is 1-step.

Does Blue Guardian or Take Profit Trader have a higher profit split?

Take Profit Trader offers a higher maximum profit split. Blue Guardian ranges from 85% to 85%, while Take Profit Trader ranges from 80% to 90%.

Can I trade news on Blue Guardian and Take Profit Trader?

Blue Guardian allows news trading, while Take Profit Trader allows it. Both firms have the same news trading policy.

Which has better drawdown rules, Blue Guardian or Take Profit Trader?

Blue Guardian uses static (floor never moves) (8%), while Take Profit Trader uses trailing eod (floor moves up at end of day) (3%). Blue Guardian's static drawdown is more forgiving since profits create extra buffer.

Embed this comparison

<iframe src="https://runvigil.app/compare/blue-guardian-vs-take-profit-trader?embed=true" width="600" height="400" frameborder="0" title="Blue Guardian vs Take Profit Trader Comparison"></iframe>
VR

Vigil Research

Reviewed | Rules verified against official firm websites